Best 3 Smartphone Cameras
Best 3 Smartphone Cameras- The introduction of the Samsung S24 Ultra has added another contender to North America’s premium smartphone market, intensifying the competition between the three flagship devices. The Apple iPhone 15 Pro Max, Google Pixel 8 Pro, and Samsung S24 Ultra have striking similarities, featuring state-of-the-art displays, HDR-compliant photography and videography, and a 5X telephoto lens to enhance the capabilities of their primary and ultra-wide cameras. ,
In Canada, the mobile phone market is largely dominated by three large players: Samsung, Apple and Google. Other companies like Motorola or LG have a lower share. The scenario bears some resemblance to that in the U.S. It’s the same in the U.S., where more competitors are vying for customers’ attention but the top brands still dominate. To evaluate these leading brands, we conducted tests focused on their photographic and videography capabilities.
Of course, while smartphones offer myriad functionalities beyond just photography, their imaging capabilities are paramount for creators. Today, with ever-improving image quality, smartphones serve as indispensable tools for visual work. A smartphone should be excellent at capturing sharp photos, perform well in low-light conditions, and offer effective AI tools for portraits and editing. With that in mind, let’s dive straight into the camera’s features.
The Ultra-Wide Cameras
The ultra-wide lenses on each of our three smartphones deliver comparable results, capable of capturing attractive close-up macro shots. Nevertheless, they have distinctive features that deserve attention.
In a close race for second (or third, depending on perspective), we have a tie between the Samsung S24 Ultra and the iPhone 15 Pro Max. Both cameras share a comparable 13mm full-frame equivalent focal length, 12-megapixel resolution, and the same f/2.2 aperture. This impasse leaves no decisive winner. Both devices offer a pleasant experience for close-up shots and deliver mediocre results in low-light settings.
The undisputed champion has emerged with the Google Pixel 8 Pro. Google has upgraded its camera hardware in its latest device, with improvements in all aspects. Specifically, the ultra-wide camera boasts an impressive 11mm full-frame equivalent width, along with a stunning f/1.95 aperture and a staggering 48-megapixel sensor. With increased light intake and higher resolution as well as an expanded field of view, Google differentiates itself from the competition.
The Main Cameras
The primary camera of a smartphone is of paramount importance, serving as the cornerstone for creating complex depth maps for portrait photography and supplying data to enhance other camera functionalities. This plays an important role in low-light scenarios and when a higher megapixel count is demanded. Given its versatile responsibilities, it has to excel in performance.
In third place is the Samsung S24 Ultra, which boasts a commendable camera setup overall but falls short compared to its counterparts. Although it captures impressive images, it has a tendency to over-process, which has been criticized by S23 users. Color rendition varies, with some shots appearing overly vibrant or harsh. Additionally, the 200-megapixel mode, while interesting, sees limited use due to its JPEG-only format, substantial storage requirement, and minimal noticeable detail enhancement in specific scenarios.
The Apple iPhone 15 Pro Max took the second spot thanks to its images with pleasingly warm tones and commendable overall performance. It has a level of detail comparable to the Samsung S24 Ultra but avoids the problem of harsh over-sharpening. Additionally, users have the facility to increase contrast as desired post-capture.
Once again, the Google Pixel 8 Pro wins in this category, with a main camera that excels at capturing intricate and fine details, outperforming its rivals. Despite slight differences in specifications in Google’s favor, the results consistently lean towards better results, with natural and well-balanced colors providing users with a neutral base for subsequent editing. Additionally, the physically larger sensor facilitates shallow depth of field, which sets it apart from its competitors.
The 5x Telephoto Cameras
With the Samsung 24 Ultra making a surprising change from the famous 10x to 5x lens, all three smartphones now boast a comparable range. Although there are still varying levels of digital zoom available on all cameras, we’re only focusing on the physical lens. It’s worth mentioning that the S24 Ultra also includes a 3x lens, albeit with lower specifications, which doesn’t effectively bridge the small gap between 1x and 5x on the new phone.
Moving to the rear, the iPhone 15 Pro Max features a new compact 5X lens with a modest 12-megapixel resolution. Although this may not significantly impact image quality on social media platforms, it becomes apparent in scenarios involving printing, cropping, or displaying on a large screen. Compared to its rivals, the iPhone falls short of delivering the same level of detail, revealing its weakness in these situations.
The Samsung S24 Ultra takes second place with its impressively stabilized 5x lens, which ensures sharp photos. Its only drawback is its slightly slower f/3.4 aperture, compared to its competitors’ f/2.8. Still, the admirable addition of the 5x lens and 48-megapixel sensor enables comparable results to the S23 Ultra’s 10x lens even with the 10x cropped lens.
Once again, the Google Pixel 8 Pro wins and benefits greatly from its latest hardware update. The 8 Pro’s 5x lens boasts impressive specifications: a 48-megapixel sensor, equivalent to 112mm on a full-frame camera, with an f/2.8 aperture, resulting in consistently stable images. Its slightly brighter lens gives it a slight edge over the S24 Ultra in this latest comparison.
Portrait Modes
Portrait mode is a common feature I use on any phone I carry. Thanks to the amalgamation of depth maps, multiple lenses, and diverse points of focus, all three smartphones can produce images with a shallow depth-of-field appearance. This capability proves particularly beneficial for traditional portraits, yet I also use it to combine product and macro shots with lightly blurred backgrounds.
All three smartphones offer post-shot portrait mode capabilities, allowing users to adjust the level of blur as per their preference. Interestingly, the Google Pixel 8 Pro lacks Portrait Mode functionality with the new 5x lens, which requires depth-of-field adjustment after capturing the image.
The Google Pixel 8 Pro is estimated to rank lower in portrait mode performance. Google has faced ongoing challenges in making subjects effectively blend into the background, and that’s evident here. Portrait mode often results in noticeable halos around subjects, with background areas that should be blurry remaining clear. The transitions between sharp and soft areas are noticeably less natural than on other instruments. Additionally, it’s important to note that the Pixel uses a 1.5x focal length for Portrait mode, which is different from the 1x focal length used by other competing phones.
The Samsung S24 Ultra takes second place with its exceptional ability to effectively identify focus areas. In particular, it beats Google in handling hair details, although it sometimes opts for cropping or excessive blurring to manage stray hairs, which can look unnatural. Nonetheless, this approach generally gives more solid results than visible halos, making it a preferred option for individuals with shorter hairstyles.
Despite the somewhat disappointing details from its 5x lens, the iPhone 15 Pro Max has emerged as the winner. Apple took inspiration from the famous photographic portrait lens for the Bokeh effect in the 15 series, resulting in solid results. Subjects seamlessly integrate with their surroundings and transition smoothly from clear to blurry areas. Hair is rendered more naturally, giving iPhone pictures a distinctive “classic” camera aesthetic.
Night Photography
A major drawback of smartphones is their relatively small sensor size, which particularly affects low-light photography. To address this, phones use techniques like shooting multiple frames and applying noise reduction algorithms. This approach often enables good handheld shots to be captured even in low-light environments. Although tripods can increase stability, they are rarely used with phones due to their impracticality.
The iPhone has a Night Mode feature, although it is considered the least versatile among its counterparts. Capped at 12 megapixels, it exhibits more noise in photos, yet it still retains commendable color accuracy in low-light environments. However, its Night Mode operates automatically, leaving users unable to manually activate it for specific scenarios, such as increasing shutter speed for better light capture or independently addressing sharp contrasts and shadow intensity. to do.
The Samsung S24 Ultra took second place in the race. Similar to the iPhone 15 series, it has a maximum resolution of 12 megapixels. Still, it employs significant noise reduction and sharpening, resulting in little compromise in tonal subtlety. Despite its heavy-handed “nitography” processing, the Samsung impresses with its effectiveness in low-light environments, delivering remarkable detail beyond expectations.
Google Pixel 8 Pro has claimed the top spot, building on the stellar track record set by its predecessors. It features 50-megapixel images synthesized from multiple shots, providing commendable noise management and abundant detail. Night mode captures impressively vibrant colors and high-quality shots, while its performance on par with larger-sensor cameras, especially when used with a tripod, is remarkable.
Also Read: Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra
Also Read: Samsung Galaxy S24 vs Apple iPhone 15
Also Read: Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra complete review
Videography
Smartphones have evolved into useful camera for content creators, especially in the field of video production. With Reels and short-form videos dominating the platform, the smartphone emerges as a versatile and powerful tool, always present and ready for action. Gone are the days of just point-and-shoot functionality; Modern phones boast impressive video recording capabilities, which perfectly complement their on-the-go convenience.
There may be some improvement in Google Pixel 8 Pro. Its 4K video lacks detail and relies on its overly processed aesthetic to impress. While everyday users won’t mind, those in the content creation field may want to look for better options elsewhere.
The Samsung S24 Ultra is known for its comprehensive features, 8K recording mode, and better manual controls. Among Android phones, it ranks highest in offering unique capabilities, while third-party apps further enhance its potential.
The Apple iPhone 15 Pro dominates the video scene, offering a versatile Log profile that produces natural tones and a wide dynamic range. Although accessing advanced video capabilities may require downloading apps like Black Magic’s software, the exceptional results justify the effort. Additionally, Apple ensures consistently locked-off frame rates and an HDR profile that undergoes superior processing and receives universal acceptance.
The Big Three Smartphone Face-Off: Final Scores
The Google Pixel 8 Pro stands out due to its updated hardware, especially its individual lenses, which contribute significantly to its appeal. I’m particularly impressed by the raw file quality and overall color reproduction of the pixels. However, I wouldn’t recommend it for advanced video applications. As a photographer, I firmly believe that it offers the highest image quality out of the three phones we tested.
The iPhone 15 Pro Max ranks second in terms of highest video quality and delivers compelling portrait shots. The images it produces are spectacular. While Apple simplifies the experience for casual users by hiding manual controls, third-party apps offer options for those wanting advanced photo adjustments.
While the S24 Ultra may come in last place overall, it claims second place thanks to its remarkable versatility. It excels at handling a wide range of tasks, making it a convenient choice for many users. Additionally, its comprehensive camera interface is commendable, although it may seem challenging to some owners.
It’s worth noting that both Google and Samsung phones offer complementary AI editing features, some of which leverage cloud-based servers for the computational heavy lifting. However, despite the promise of this cutting-edge technology, the results are disappointing. As databases become more complex, substantial performance improvements are expected, which will undoubtedly impact future assessments. For now, I will be using these features sparingly, waiting for substantial progress.
Finally, existing Apple ecosystem users are likely to remain attached to their devices, while Android users enjoy more flexibility to explore different brands. We aim to provide information about which phone may be best for you.
Follow my: WhatsApp channel
